The Solon Community Church was founded in 1834 in Solon, OH as a “fellowship of Christians in a Congregational manner” by a group of men led by Rev. John Steward. In 1836, a church building was raised and dedicated, and the first minister was called. Due to financial difficulties in the first decade, the church was unable to be self-supporting and in 1840, it was taken under the care of the Cleveland Presbytery and their Home Missions Board. The church became fully Presbyterian in 1871. In 1841, some families within the church separated to found the Disciples of Christ church nearby. In 1853, the church enlarged their meeting house and in 1897, the church building burned to the ground. While the new building was being built, the congregation held services in the schoolhouse and the Disciple church which later burned down in 1899. The new church building broke ground in 1897, laid the cornerstone in September 1897 and was dedicated in January 1898.

In 1922, the Solon Presbyterian church and the Disciple church formed a federation to become the Solon Federated Church with services alternating between the two church buildings until eventually the entirety of services were held in the Presbyterian church. In 1924, a parsonage was built next to the Presbyterian church. Since the church served the entire Protestant community in Solon, the church changed its name to the Solon Community Church in 1948. Shortly after, in 1951, some of the members of the Disciple church decided to reform their own church and refurbished their church building which became the Pioneer Memorial Church in 1953. Also in 1953, Solon Community Church was forced to buy back their building and parsonage from the Cleveland Presbytery after a court trial regarding the question of ownership. In 1955, the church returned to the congregational denomination by joining the Congregational Christian Conference and in 1961, joined the United Church of Christ formed from the merger of the Congregational Christian and Evangelical and Reformed churches.

To keep up with the growth of Solon, the church purchased land in 1957 for a new building and broke ground in 1960 with the cornerstone laid in September 1960, and a dedication in April 1961. In 1962, a parsonage was purchased on Linden Dr. and was later replaced by a parsonage on Copley Ave in 1972. The Copley Ave parsonage was sold in 1983 to the then minister Rev. Mark Thomas. Over the years, various renovations and building improvements occurred, notably in 1975, 1995-1997, 2003 with the new Congregational Life Center which was dedicated in January 2006, and 2007. As the church entered the 2020s, membership declined until the church decided to permanently close in 2022 with the last service held in November 2022.